When old versions of you show up at work
or, understanding what you're carrying into the room
Work has a way of waking up parts of us we thought we’d outgrown.
You can move forward professionally, take on more visible roles, and be widely regarded as capable… and still find yourself unsettled by moments that seem, on the surface, fairly ordinary. A comment lingers longer than expected. A meeting leaves you tense for days. A role you worked hard to earn suddenly feels exposing rather than energizing.
When that happens, it’s easy to assume something is wrong now—that you’re underprepared, out of your depth, or somehow not built for this level of responsibility. But often, what’s being stirred up has less to do with the present moment than with experiences that shaped you much earlier in your career.
The past isn’t gone. It’s patterned.
A former client of mine—let’s call her Anna—had built a highly respected career in public health. She was known for her steadiness, her judgment, her ability to navigate complexity under pressure. When she accepted a high-profile role in government, it looked like a natural progression.
Internally, it felt like regression.
Almost immediately, Anna began doubting herself in ways that were new and unsettling. She grew anxious before meetings. She became acutely sensitive to tone, status, and feedback. After speaking, she would mentally replay her comments, convinced she’d revealed some fundamental gap.
What made this disorienting was that nothing objectively negative was happening. Her colleagues were engaged. Her supervisor was supportive. Her performance was strong.
And yet her body responded as if the stakes were far higher.
As we slowed things down, we traced this reaction back to her graduate training. Anna had come of age professionally in an elite program where intimidation was framed as rigor. Several professors used public critique and subtle humiliation as teaching tools. Questions were treated as exposures. Authority was unpredictable.
At the time, Anna adapted brilliantly. She became hyper-prepared and learned to anticipate criticism before it came. She made herself intellectually airtight. That strategy worked. She succeeded. She moved on. Except her nervous system never got the memo.
Her new role didn’t create anxiety—it activated an old internal map, one drawn in an environment where visibility carried real risk. Intellectually, she knew she belonged. Psychologically, she was responding to an earlier chapter.
This is how implicit memory works: the past doesn’t show up as a story. It shows up as sensation, vigilance, and reflex.
When failure gets frozen in time
Another client, Mark, had a parallel experience—though his story unfolded very differently.
Early in his career, Mark joined a start-up that collapsed publicly and painfully. The failure was chaotic and highly visible. Investors blamed leadership. Careers stalled. Relationships fractured. Mark internalized the experience as evidence that he had misjudged, over-trusted, and failed to see what others apparently saw.
Years later, he was a senior executive at a stable organization. Colleagues described him as thoughtful, disciplined, and deeply responsible.
But when his team faced uncertainty or risk, Mark became rigid. He over-planned. He struggled to delegate. He avoided bold decisions, even when the downside was limited.
“I don’t think I’m afraid of failing now,” he said at one point. “I think I’m afraid of that feeling again.”
What Mark was describing is something psychologists have long observed: unresolved experiences don’t fade—they flatten. They remain frozen at the emotional intensity of the original moment and get reactivated when something feels even vaguely similar.
In those moments, the brain doesn’t distinguish between then and now. The body reacts as if the original threat has returned.
Professional life has a developmental history, too
We tend to think of our professional selves as separate from our psychological development. But careers have formative periods, too—early mentors, first failures, environments where we learned what was rewarded, punished, or ignored.
If we don’t reflect on those shaping experiences, they don’t disappear. They quietly influence how we lead, speak, take risks, and respond to authority.
Most of us already accept this idea when it comes to parenting.
We know that unexamined childhood experiences can spill into how we parent—that if we don’t reflect on how we were disciplined, soothed, pressured, or dismissed, we’re likely to reenact those patterns or overcorrect for them with our own children.
Professional life follows the same logic. Unprocessed professional experiences don’t show up as memories. They show up as leadership styles, communication patterns, and emotional reflexes.
Why coaching helps when insight isn’t enough
This is where coaching can be uniquely valuable—not because it offers techniques or productivity frameworks, but because it creates a space to integrate experience rather than simply outgrow it.
In coaching, the work often involves:
distinguishing present-day challenge from past threat
identifying strategies that once protected you but now constrain you
noticing when an old internal narrative has been activated
building the capacity to stay grounded when visibility, evaluation, or authority are in play
For Anna, the shift came when she could say, without judgment: I’m not bad at this job. I’m having an old reaction in a new context. That recognition didn’t eliminate discomfort. But it restored choice. She could prepare thoughtfully rather than compulsively. She could tolerate anxiety without interpreting it as danger. She could speak without mentally scanning for punishment.
For Mark, progress meant finally allowing himself to grieve a professional failure he’d never fully metabolized. Doing so loosening his grip on control in situations that no longer required it.
Reflection Questions
If any of this resonates, these questions may be worth sitting with:
Are there moments at work where my reaction feels bigger than the situation warrants?
What earlier professional experiences might have shaped how I respond to authority, risk, or visibility?
Which strategies once helped me succeed, but may now be limiting my growth?
Where might I be responding to an old story rather than present reality?
Letting the present have more say
This work isn’t about fixing yourself or endlessly revisiting the past. Most of the people I work with are already capable, conscientious, and deeply invested in doing their work well.
What’s often missing isn’t insight, but the space to slow down enough to notice what’s being activated and to treat those reactions as data rather than something to override.
Unexamined professional experiences tend to resurface indirectly. Not as memories, but as tension, hesitation, over-effort, or a familiar sense of bracing. It’s easy to read those signals as evidence that something is wrong now, rather than as residue from an earlier context.
Over time, what shifts isn’t the disappearance of discomfort, but how much authority it’s given. The past doesn’t go away; it simply stops running the meeting.
For many people, that’s what makes work feel steadier again.
Read
At day cares in Minnesota, strangers are showing up at their doors as parents scramble to protect staff (19th News)
When you have to assign work no one wants to do (HBR gift link)
Reset advice for working mothers who are running on empty (Forbes)
They’re the top U.S. Olympic medal hopes in bobsled, and they’re also working moms (NYTimes gift link)
You're amazing. This is such a helpful post.